I grew up in a household that was very fiscally responsible. My father instilled at an early age the power of saving and investing. If I accumulated $50 in allowance he would be willing to match my savings.For a nine year, old, or any investor for that matter doubling your return annually is quite impressive. For my birthday, every year my grandfather would give me a $100 savings bond, which now that I think of it, I have no idea where those went. When I was seventeen years old I began a Roth IRA, and when I was nineteen I purchased equity in my first company that went bankrupt (GT Technologies). Not only was I encouraged to save but my parents always preached the importance of paying your debt. Even to the point where having debt was like subscribing to the Black Plague. Even if debt couldn’t wipe out one third of the European population it could definitely wipe out a large portion of the stock market (i.e. Long Term Capital Management had liabilities over $100 billion, this translated to an effective leverage ratio of more than 250-to-1 and a government bailout of multiple banks). As a recent college graduate, I have my first bout with debt in the form of student loans.
As 2016 comes to an end, most recent collegiate graduates are familiar with the statistics revolving around student loans: In the United States there is approximately $1.26 trillion in total US student loan debt, 44.2 million Americans had student loan debt, student loan delinquency rates are around 11.1%, and average student loan payments for borrowers aged 20 to 30 years amount to $351 per month (Student Loan Hero). According to Student Loan Hero, the debt statistics by student loan status are as follows:
- Loans in repayment – $468.1 billion; 15.7 million borrowers
- Loans in deferment – $101.7 billion; 3.4 million borrowers
- Loans in forbearance – $102.8 billion; 2.7 million borrowers
- Loans in default – $63.2 billion; 3.9 million borrowers
- Loans in grace period – $42.6 billion; 1.7 million borrowers
It’s no secret that students have become increasingly dependent on student loans to fund their four years at both public and private schools. The Class of 2016 graduate has $37,172 in student loan debt, up six percent from last year and the 2017 student loan debt is only expected to increase. With more of an emphasis on the importance of college education, it seems that these costs won’t be going away anytime soon. With over $1 trillion in government funded student loans there has been a misguided hope of debt forgiveness. The impact of student loans is one of reasons Bernie Sanders was a popular candidate. In a current low-growth, low interest rate economy, these debt forgiveness programs could even be harmful to the people they’re meant to help. Ohio University developmental economist Julia Paxton states:
“One of the problems of debt forgiveness is that it sets a precedent that similar loans in the future will also be forgiven. Although the loans are allocated toward education, money is fungible and will have the net impact of increasing the spending ability of students in other areas of their lives. As the expectation of repayment obligation falls, borrowers may enter into a situation where they take on higher levels of debt and take more risks. This will lead to a weakened ability to repay, creating a vicious cycle that hurts the financial sector and the credit ratings of the borrowers.”
And with a Precedent-Elect that aims to lower taxes and increase infrastructure spending, the ability for government funding of tuition will be increasingly sparse. While the idea of young Americans entering into the work force with mountains of debt is in no way uplifting, awareness of the loan management strategies helps to alleviate the load.
From the first student loan meeting to your last payment you hear the same advice: Make your loan payments fit your budget even if that means student loan refinancing, have a debt management strategy, focus on long term planning and find the payoff date, avoid repayment programs, pay off higher interest rate loans first, private loans offer less flexibility, etc. etc. The list goes on and on, but one of the most worn out pieces of advice is to pay off your debt early. In my household, this has been a common theme emphasized by my parents. My sister paid off her $17,000 in eight months, saving approximately $7,000 in interest that she would have accumulated if she followed the ten-year payment plan. Using a basic loan amortization schedule, a $25,000 student loan with 5.0% interest with a 10-year payback period would cost $208 a month. By paying $700 a month instead of $288 enables the borrower to repay the loan in just over 3 years. By paying the principal down more quickly, you would be paying lower interest charges. By paying extra, the entire loan would cost $27,000 rather than $31,000. While it seems like a no brainer to pay off debt early, an intelligent investor knows that single-minded returns tend to mislead and absolute returns mislead absolutely.
Would you rather invest in a security that offers 5% or 8% returns, ceterus paribus? Any rationale investor would choose the latter. As you look at your personal and financial goals, it’s time to compare interest rates. Is paying off student loans early right for you or should you focus on your saving goals and invest in the ever enticing stock market. If you have an interest rate over 5%, you may want to make paying off debt your main priority. High interest rates can tack on a lot of extra money to your balance, making the repayment period even longer. But if you have a low interest rate—especially around 2%—you may be able to get better returns on your money in the stock market. With investing, you take advantage of compound interest and put your money to work for you over time. Both options have there benefits and depend on the risk tolerance of the borrower.
Pros of Waiting to Payoff Loans and Investing
- Compounding interest and higher investment returns
- Many employers match investments in 401K
- Invest in tax advantage retirement accounts (i.e. Roth IRA, 401K)
- Could receive tax deductions on student loans
- Potential student loan forgiveness programs
Pros of Paying Off Student Loans Early
- Guaranteed return
- Many investments are taxable at a higher rate (15% if you are in a 25% or higher tax bracket)
- Clean Conscious
- Good Credit Score!
As for myself, I am comfortable prepaying an interest rate of 5% on my student loans and forgoing a rigorous investment plan. On Friday December 17th, the Dow Jones had risen 10% for 2016 and continues to approach 20,000. Wall Street forecasts for 2017 are unsurprisingly bullish as the year ends on a strong note. While there is a chance that markets will continue to outperform in 2017, major indices continue to appear overvalued. While I will pay off my loans as soon as possible, I also set aside money to max out my 401K, add to my Roth IRA, and include a safety net in case of emergencies. So whether you choose to pay off your student loans early or to invest your money, continue to make minimum payments toward your federal loans, and choose a repayment term that works for you.
http://www.bankrate.com/finance/college-finance/repay-college-loans-fast-1.aspx#ixzz4TmC7uSWW
https://studentloanhero.com/calculators/student-loan-payoff-vs-invest-calculator/